Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
'Why is this message in Spam? We've found that lots of messages from mailer.effifinance.com are spam'
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
Comments
8 comments
Hey Jaime,
I'm not by any means an expert in this stuff, but I do know that switching IP Addresses can cause a shift in email behavior. One thing I've wondered about Act-On is if we're on a shared IP Address, or does each account have its own Dedicated IP. If you've moved from a Dedicated IP address to a Shared one, it will probably have an impact until the email addresses you're sending to begin to recognize the new IP. With your account being so new, I'm wondering if that has an effect on your email performance.
EDIT: According to this Act-On White Paper, it is recommended to do a 'warming' of your email list after moving to a Dedicated server:
https://university.act-on.com/User_Guides/Outbound_Marketing/Optimizing_Email_Deliverability/03_Warming_a_Dedicated_IP
------------------------------
Justin Williamson
Foundation Group
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
Have you ever tried Litmus before? We use it along with Act-on, and it has really saved us a lot of time and solved some mysteries. They have a fantastic spam checker that runs your email through a multitude of spam clients and gives you specific details on what could be causing the issue. Even if you don't use Litmus on an ongoing basis, signing up for a month could help you figure this out.
------------------------------
--------------
Angelo Outlaw
Senior Interactive Designer & Developer
Verimatrix, Inc.
--------------
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:21
From: Justin Williamson
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hey Jaime,
I'm not by any means an expert in this stuff, but I do know that switching IP Addresses can cause a shift in email behavior. One thing I've wondered about Act-On is if we're on a shared IP Address, or does each account have its own Dedicated IP. If you've moved from a Dedicated IP address to a Shared one, it will probably have an impact until the email addresses you're sending to begin to recognize the new IP. With your account being so new, I'm wondering if that has an effect on your email performance.
EDIT: According to this Act-On White Paper, it is recommended to do a 'warming' of your email list after moving to a Dedicated server:
https://university.act-on.com/User_Guides/Outbound_Marketing/Optimizing_Email_Deliverability/03_Warming_a_Dedicated_IP
------------------------------
Justin Williamson
Foundation Group
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
------------------------------
Becky Montchal
Director of Marketing, Symmetry Software
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 16:47
From: Angelo Outlaw
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Sorry to hear about the spam issues Jaime. I can definitely sympathize.
Have you ever tried Litmus before? We use it along with Act-on, and it has really saved us a lot of time and solved some mysteries. They have a fantastic spam checker that runs your email through a multitude of spam clients and gives you specific details on what could be causing the issue. Even if you don't use Litmus on an ongoing basis, signing up for a month could help you figure this out.
------------------------------
--------------
Angelo Outlaw
Senior Interactive Designer & Developer
Verimatrix, Inc.
--------------
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:21
From: Justin Williamson
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hey Jaime,
I'm not by any means an expert in this stuff, but I do know that switching IP Addresses can cause a shift in email behavior. One thing I've wondered about Act-On is if we're on a shared IP Address, or does each account have its own Dedicated IP. If you've moved from a Dedicated IP address to a Shared one, it will probably have an impact until the email addresses you're sending to begin to recognize the new IP. With your account being so new, I'm wondering if that has an effect on your email performance.
EDIT: According to this Act-On White Paper, it is recommended to do a 'warming' of your email list after moving to a Dedicated server:
https://university.act-on.com/User_Guides/Outbound_Marketing/Optimizing_Email_Deliverability/03_Warming_a_Dedicated_IP
------------------------------
Justin Williamson
Foundation Group
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
------------------------------
Dom Ogier
Marketing Manager, Guernsey Finance LBG
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
------------------------------
--------------
Angelo Outlaw
Senior Interactive Designer & Developer
Verimatrix, Inc.
--------------
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-26-2017 11:40
From: Sean Chu
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hi Jaime,
Prepare for a huge wall of text...
There are many factors that come in to play that affect your external deliverability. These can be separated in to 3 separate categories: technical setup, content, and reputation. I will outline each below.
Given the statement above, the opposite is actually different. If you do decide to use a dedicated IP, your bad actions or good actions, no matter how granular they may be, are taken in much more extremes and are only affect you. Also in order to actually use a dedicated IP, you need to have a certain level of mailings sent from the server in order to keep this IP address 'warm' in a sense. A 'cold' or improperly warmed up IP address will have lower deliverability than those in a shared pool.
For more information and an excellent read, please see our Email Deliverability Best Practices eBook. This has a wealth of knowledge on the matter and further explains how each item comes in to play. Also our support team is well versed in evaluating your account for possible issues that may be affecting your deliverability. They can be contacted by emailing support@act-on.com or calling 877-530-1555 option #2.
I hope I was able to clarify and answer everyone's questions and concerns. If anyone has any follow up questions to anything mentioned above, please feel free to post to this discussion or if you need to go in to detail, please shoot me a message and I would be happy to answer for you.
/huge wall-o-text OFF
Cheers!
------------------------------
Sean Chu
Sr Solutions Engineer, Act-On Software
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
I'm happy that you asked the question, I was looking into spam issues myself. And thanks Sean for your helpful answer.
From a practical perspective, I just wanted to add some thoughts:
In the past, in a previous job, I had the luxury of an external company that was looking into deliverability:
1 - by creating several templates that would be reused for different campaigns. These templates would already take into account structural necessities/image/text-ratio,... to improve spam-scores.
2 - by reviewing our finalised emails and going through the points Sean's mentionning before sending.
It may be worth investing at least at the beginning until you get a better feeling for spam-issues.
Also, act-on has a spam-check you probably already have seen, not sure if it considers all, but it gives you score on how good your mail performs for different firewalls. I had a discussion about Spam scores with one of the act-on experts, and here are some links she provided me. Can be helpful for you too?
Quote - 'When it comes to the spam complaint check, you are correct you want to be on the lower side for most of them. The hard part is that each one Spam Assassin, Barracuda, etc have different thresholds. The best thing to do is to check the websites for each as these thresholds may sometimes change. Also, one thing to note is that each company can set their threshold to be more aggressive meaning 1 or below will not be considered spam.
Barracuda - The spam score ranges from 0 (definitely not spam) to 9 or greater (definitely spam). Based on this score, the Barracuda Spam Firewall can take one of four actions. https://campus.barracuda.com/product/emailsecuritygateway/knowledgebase/50160000000IAJ7AAO/how-is-the-spam-score-calculated-and-emails-categorized-on-my-barracuda-spam-firewall/
Spam Assassin - By default, SpamAssassin considers messages with a score of 5 to be spam; however, you can adjust the spam score limit according to your preference. http://support.hostgator.com/articles/how-to-use-spam-assassin
Symantec.Cloud – does not publicly identify their scoring model. MessageLabs another product for spam score by Symantec but how they do the calculation is a little different than the other spam score vendors. Please read more about them in the article at the bottom of this email.
Outlook - The Microsoft Outlook filter scores from 0-10 on the High sensitivity rating, with 0 being the highest (passing) and 10 being the lowest (failing). Outlook rates an email with a 6.0 or higher (out of 10) as a failure. A lower score (lower than 6.0) is considered a passing score with the High sensitivity rating.
Here is an article about the spam scores overall:
https://litmus.com/help/testing/spam-scoring/' - Quote end
------------------------------
Esra
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
In a recent email send-out I noticed that the bounce rate was unusually high. It's our monthly newsletter send-out so bounces shouldn't vary that much month over month, especially since we try to scrub our lists at regular intervals. Digging into the bounces I concluded that a large part of the 'new' bounces were email addresses that we had previously had no problem delivering to. However they had in common that the recipient hadn't interacted (opened, clicked) with our messages for a long period of time. The bounce reason stated by Act-On did however vary between spam-related, other and relaying-issues. What they all had in common was that they were soft-bounces.
Is this some built in feature in Act-On that you get a soft bounce if the recipient hasn't interacted with any of your content in a long time?
Thankful to anyone who can shed some light on this issue.
------------------------------
Best regards
Johanna Adolfsson
Lead Manager, Holmen AB
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
We too have been noticing problems with deliverability. A particular problem is that our emails are being blocked on account of 'High Bulk Complaint Score'.
To help alleviate this problem, we have been advised to create an 'Envelope From: domain' address for each of our Act-On accounts. However, having spoken to our IT team, we are wondering just what benefit this will have. Ultimately, emails are being sent via Act-On's servers. As we see it, even if we create a different address, the process will be the same – emails will be sent via Act-On's servers.
Perhaps you could explain in more detail what the benefits of creating an 'Envelope From: domain' address are? It seems to us that spam filters are having an issue with Act-On as such, rather than our domains. We are currently using from address xxx@idoxgroup.com – surely changing the envelope from to xxx@yyy.idoxgroup.com would only make our emails look less legitimate, as you are a step removed from the 'core' domain and its reputation?
------------------------------
Sion Stedman
Idox Software Ltd
------------------------------
-------------------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-26-2017 11:40
From: Sean Chu
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hi Jaime,
Prepare for a huge wall of text...
There are many factors that come in to play that affect your external deliverability. These can be separated in to 3 separate categories: technical setup, content, and reputation. I will outline each below.
Given the statement above, the opposite is actually different. If you do decide to use a dedicated IP, your bad actions or good actions, no matter how granular they may be, are taken in much more extremes and are only affect you. Also in order to actually use a dedicated IP, you need to have a certain level of mailings sent from the server in order to keep this IP address 'warm' in a sense. A 'cold' or improperly warmed up IP address will have lower deliverability than those in a shared pool.
For more information and an excellent read, please see our Email Deliverability Best Practices eBook. This has a wealth of knowledge on the matter and further explains how each item comes in to play. Also our support team is well versed in evaluating your account for possible issues that may be affecting your deliverability. They can be contacted by emailing support@act-on.com or calling 877-530-1555 option #2.
I hope I was able to clarify and answer everyone's questions and concerns. If anyone has any follow up questions to anything mentioned above, please feel free to post to this discussion or if you need to go in to detail, please shoot me a message and I would be happy to answer for you.
/huge wall-o-text OFF
Cheers!
------------------------------
Sean Chu
Sr Solutions Engineer, Act-On Software
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 10-25-2017 15:04
From: Jaime Edge
Subject: Help - Marketing Email's Going to SPAM
Hello, everyone.
I am especially excited to be a member of this new community :)
...but I'm also in quite a pickle.
My company has been using Act-On for about 3 months now, and I've been noticing that our open rates have been steadily dropping since that time. Initially, I thought this may just be a subject-line issue, but this week an email that was sent to 1500+ contacts was opened by only 14 contacts.
I immediately sent a few test emails to some close friends who hadn't received emails from our domain before, and the messages went directly to SPAM.
Explanation from Gmail (see attached screenshot):
Do you have any suggestions on how I can get my messaging out of people's SPAM folders for future campaigns?
For reference, since we started using Act-On (about 3 months ago), we've received approximately 7 spam complaints and 25 unique opt-outs.
Any help, advice, etc. would be much appreciated.
Thank you all! And welcome to the new community :D
Jaime
------------------------------
Jaime Edge
Vice President, Marketing, EFFI Finance, Inc.
------------------------------
Please sign in to leave a comment.